A novel locus on mouse chromosome 7 that influences survival after infection with tick-borne encephalitis virus

Tick-borne encephalitis (TBE) is the main tick-borne viral infection in Eurasia. It is prevalent across the entire continent from Japan to France [1]. The disease is caused by tick-borne encephalitis virus (TBEV), a flavivirus of the family Flaviviridae, which besides TBEV includes West Nile virus (WNV), dengue virus (DENV), Zika virus (ZIKV), yellow fever virus (YFV), Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV), and several other viruses causing extensive morbidity and mortality in humans. Ticks act as both the vector and reservoir for TBEV. The main hosts are small rodents, with humans being accidental hosts. In Europe and Russia between 5000 and 13,000 clinical cases of TBE are reported annually, with a large annual fluctuation [2]. The highest incidence of TBE is reported in western Siberia, in the Czech Republic, Estonia, Slovenia and Lithuania, but the prevalence of the disease is believed to be higher than actually reported [1, 2]. TBEV may produce a variety of clinical symptoms, from an asymptomatic disease to a fever and acute or chronic progressive encephalitis. The outcome of infection depends on the strain of virus [1], as well as on the genotype [3], sex and age of the host [4], and on the environmental and social factors [1]. Environmental and social factors influence also risk of infection.

Genetic influence on susceptibility to TBEV-induced disease has been analyzed by two main strategies: a hypothesis-independent phenotype-driven approach and a hypothesis-driven approach. Application of a genome-wide search (hypothesis-independent approach) in mouse led to identification of the gene Oas1 (2′-5′-oligoadenylate synthetase gene) [5, 6]. A stop codon in exon 4 of the gene Oas1b (a natural knockout) present in majority of mouse laboratory strains causes production of protein lacking 30% of the C terminal sequence [5]. This part of molecule seems to be critical for tetramerization required for OAS1B activity leading to degradation of viral RNA. Thus, this mutation makes majority of mouse laboratory strains susceptible to flaviviruses [6, 7]. Human ortholog to this gene (OAS1) also modifies susceptibility to other flaviviruses (WNV) [8, 9], whereas OAS2 and OAS3 localized in the same cluster on chromosome 12q24.2 influence response to TBEV [3]. The polymorphic sites associated in OAS2 and OAS3 with susceptibility to TBEV did not resulted in amino acid changes, thus mechanisms of susceptibility control is not known [3]. The hypothesis-driven approach has focused on genes that encode molecules indicated to be involved in antiviral response by mechanistic studies [9]. These candidate genes studies revealed that polymorphisms in CD209/DC-SIGN [10], CCR5 [11, 12], TLR3 [12, 13], IL10 [14] and IFNL3/IL28B [14] influence susceptibility to TBEV in humans.

Our previous study has shown that both after subcutaneous and intracerebral inoculation of European prototypic TBEV, BALB/c mice exhibited intermediate susceptibility to the infection, STS mice were highly resistant, whereas the strain CcS-11, which carries 12.5% of the STS genome on the background of the genome of the strain BALB/c [15], is even more susceptible than its two parents—BALB/c and STS [16]. Importantly, mouse orthologs of human TBEV controlling genes: Oas1b, Cd209, Tlr3, Ccr5, Il10 and Ifnl3 are in CcS-11 localized on segments derived from the strain BALB/c (Fig. 1), so they are identical in both BALB/c and CcS-11 and hence cannot be responsible for the phenotypic difference of the two strains. Therefore, the difference must be due to a presently unknown locus, which could be detected by a linkage study of a cross between BALB/c and CcS-11. Thus, we have generated a F₂ intercross between BALB/c and CcS-11 and performed a linkage and bioinformatics analysis. These studies revealed a novel suggestive locus on mouse chromosome 7 containing 9 potential candidate genes.

Binary trait linkage analysis revealed a suggestive locus on chromosome 7 near D7Nds5 affecting the binary trait (death/survival) (LOD = 2.15), with a corresponding genome-scan-adjusted P value = 0.12 (Fig. 2a). The 1-LOD support interval spans from D7Mit25 to D7Nds1. The STS allele both in homozygotes and heterozygotes was associated with a higher death rate in each of the three separate experimental groups (Fig. 2b), and in the pooled data (Fig. 3a), so its presence in CcS-11 enhances even more the overall susceptibility determined by the BALB/c background. Ruffled fur was observed in only 8% of mice, so it was not suitable for statistical analysis. Paresis was less frequent than mortality (n = 60 vs. 102) and not all paretic mice died, but the two phenotypes were positively correlated (Pearson correlation 0.53). Moreover, frequency of paresis in the three D7Nds5 genotypes (Fig. 3b), although not significantly different, was biologically compatible with the survival data, because D7Nds5 CC homozygotes had the highest survival rate, and the lowest percentage of paresis.

One of these genes, Cd33, carried in the strain STS a nonsense mutation. Other changes in the strain STS in comparison with BALB/c (and the reference strain C57BL/6) represented single amino acids change in Siglec E, KLK1B22, KLK1B16, FUT2 and OTOG. The BALB/c strain had in comparison with STS (and the reference strain C57BL/6) deletion of two amino acids in GRWD1, insertion of four amino acids in MKRN3 and single amino acid change in and ABCC6 (Table 1).

CD33 and Siglec E belong to family of CD33-related sialic-acid-binding immunoglobulin-like lectins (CD33rSiglecs). They are ITIM-containing inhibitory receptors, which are involved in regulation of inflammatory and immune responses [27]. Gene Cd33 carried in the strain STS a nonsense mutation (Table 1). Product of this gene is in mouse expressed on myeloid precursors and cells of myeloid origin [28] and on microglial cells [29]. It can inhibit response to amyloid plaques and its deletion leads to protection in the mouse model of Alzheimer disease (AD) [29] and in humans some CD33 genetic variants are associated with late-onset AD [30]; its potential role in pathology of TBEV might be associated with its regulatory role in inflammatory responses. Gene Siglece carried in the strain STS a single amino acid change. Siglec E is expressed on microglia and inhibits neurotoxicity triggered by neural debris [31], which might have protective role against damage induced by flaviviruses.

A single amino acid change was present in KLK1B22 and KLK1B16. Kallikreins are serine proteases that might both help to fight infection by activating complement system [32], as well as aggravate disease symptoms by releasing bradykinin, which causes alterations in vascular permeability [33]. Their role in defense against flaviviruses has not been described. Kallikrein-bradykinin system have been described to contribute to protection against Leishmania [34] and Trypanosoma cruzi [35] parasites in mice. Interestingly, on the mouse chromosome 7 were in the strain CcS-11 mapped loci Lmr21 and Tbbr3 that control susceptibility to L. major [36] and T. b. brucei [17], respectively. However, both loci are mapped on a long chromosomal segment, thus other gene(s) might be responsible for their effect.

FUT2 have been described to influence control of a wide range of pathogens such as noroviruses [37], rotaviruses [38], HIV [39], and Escherichia coli [40] in humans, and to Helicobacter pylori in mouse [41], but its role in resistance to flaviviruses is not known.

Makorin 1 induces degradation of WNV capsid which might protect host cells [42]. The E3 ligase domain responsible for MKRN1 effect is present also in MKRN3 [43]. Thus, gene Mkrn3 might have relationship to defense against flaviviruses. Similarly, possible role of Otog, Grwd1 and Abcc6 in resistance to TBEV remains to be elucidated.

We have found a susceptibility allele of a locus on chromosome 7 in the resistant strain STS. This apparent paradox is likely caused by the fact that most inbred mouse strains were produced without an intentional selective breeding for a specific quantitative phenotype (like susceptibility to specific infections). Therefore they inherited randomly from their non-inbred ancestors susceptible alleles at some loci and resistant alleles at others, so that their overall susceptibility phenotype depends on the relative number of both types of alleles. Such finding is not unique, as susceptibility alleles originating from resistant strains were found in susceptibility studies of other infectious diseases [17, 46, 47] and colon cancer [48]. Similarly, in different in vitro tests of immune responses a low-responder allele was identified in a high responding strain [49] or vice versa [50]. Another explanation might be presence of BALB/c allele interacting with STS allele on chromosome 7. Demonstration of such interaction would require further experiments. We have already observed interaction of STS and BALB/c alleles leading to extreme phenotypes in susceptibility to L. major [51] and L. tropica [47].

Abcc6 (ATP-binding cassette, sub-family C (CFTR/MRP), member 6), mouse gene; ABCC6-human gene; ABCC6-protein (gene product); Ccr5: chemokine (C–C motif) receptor 5; Cd209: CD209 antigen; Cd33 (CD33 antigen); Fut2 (fucosyltransferase 2); Grwd1 (glutamate-rich WD repeat containing 1); Ifnl3: interferon lambda 3 (synonym Il28b); Il10: interleukin 10; Klk1b16 (kallikrein 1-related peptidase b16); Klk1b22 (kallikrein 1-related peptidase b22); Mkrn3 (makorin, ring finger protein, 3); Oas1b: 2′-5′-oligoadenylate synthetase gene; Otog (otogelin); pfu: Plaque-forming unit; RC: Recombinant congenic; s.c: Subcutaneous; Siglece (sialic acid binding Ig-like lectin E); TBE: Tick-borne encephalitis; TBEV: Tick-borne encephalitis virus; Tlr3: toll-like receptor 3.

According to current gene and protein nomenclature, mouse gene symbols are italicized, with only the first letter in upper-case (e.g. Cd33). Protein symbols are not italicized, and all letters are in upper-case (e.g. CD33). Human gene symbols are in upper-case and are italicized (e.g. CD33). Protein symbols are identical to their corresponding gene symbols except that they are not italicized (e.g. CD33).